top of page

Five Steps Judgemeadow Took to Lift Pupil Premium Grades Nearly Three Times the National Gap

1 day ago
6 min read

A GUIDE FOR PUPIL PREMIUM LEADS Judgemeadow Community College used one-to-one tutoring with Purple Ruler to lift its Pupil Premium students by 1.6 grades from their Year 10 mocks, on average: nearly three times the half grade by which disadvantaged students fall behind nationally.

A PURPLE RULER PARTNER STORY

Twenty-two of the 25 Year 11 Pupil Premium students who finished Judgemeadow Community College’s tutoring programme in 2026 beat their Year 10 mock grade at GCSE. One of them, a maths student who never missed a session, went from a grade 4 in their mock to a grade 8.


Plenty of schools offer Year 11 tutoring. Fewer can say whether it changed a single grade. Judgemeadow can: Robyn Mansfield, its Pupil Premium Champion, measured the first year with Purple Ruler, changed what the numbers showed, and measured the second.


Two cohorts compared, both taught by Purple Ruler. Judgemeadow Community College impact reports, December 2025 and August 2026; Purple Ruler lesson register, spring term 2026.
Two cohorts compared, both taught by Purple Ruler. Judgemeadow Community College impact reports, December 2025 and August 2026; Purple Ruler lesson register, spring term 2026.


The gap the money is for

Family income still shapes exam results in England. On average, disadvantaged students make just over half a grade less progress in every GCSE subject than the national average, and 27 percentage points fewer of them pass English and maths at grade 5 or above. Pupil Premium funding exists to close that gap.



Judgemeadow offers the tutoring free, in school, to every Year 11 student eligible for Pupil Premium, first come, first served. For many it is the only tutoring within reach: “a lot of them, their families can’t afford additional tuition,” Ms Mansfield says. It is open to every ability, from students below their target to those chasing the top grades. The aim, in her word, is acceleration.


“Tuition is often seen as a quick fix, but impact can be limited if attendance is poor, or it is not linked to classroom learning.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE




Sessions begin after each student’s first Year 11 mock, when they know what went wrong in the exam. The tutor builds from that paper, class tests and reports, and in maths the student also picks the topics to cover. After the next mock, they report back again. In 2025-26 Ms Mansfield added one rule:


“I put an emphasis on every tutor going over the exam paper with the students, so that they could familiarise themselves with the type of questions that they would be asked.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE



The tutoring is not a standalone fix. It worked best, the school says, because it was aligned with classroom teaching, mock exam analysis, teacher feedback, the misconceptions teachers had already identified and the school’s existing interventions. It builds on high-quality teaching rather than standing in for it.



Judgemeadow already ran group interventions and had also trialled tutoring in groups of three, which meant that progress through topics was dependent on all students reaching the same point before moving on. One-to-one teaching was the thing it could not offer itself. That is what Purple Ruler provides: a tutor for every student, live in school straight after lessons, the same tutor each week, and sessions planned from that student’s own mocks, building on what has already been taught in lessons and targeting knowledge gaps and misconceptions already identified by the school.



“Whereas one-to-one, it’s at their pace, their individual needs. It means that it’s fully targeted on everything that they’re finding difficult.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE



The school chose maths and English language, the two grades colleges ask for. In the spring term 19 students were taught maths and seven English, in weekly 45-minute sessions, and 89% of lessons were taught by the student’s usual tutor. “Having that one-to-one input made, like, a massive difference,” Ms Mansfield says.



The first cohort, in 2024-25, settled the point. Students who came to more than seven sessions improved by 1.69 grades on average; those who came to fewer improved by 0.6.


Each dot is one student in the first cohort, 2024-25. Source: Judgemeadow Community College impact report, December 2025.



The second year was therefore built around turning up. The letter to families says plainly that a session missed without good reason gives the place to another student; this year many families returned it the next day. A member of staff reminds every student in person each week and follows up every absence. Sessions moved off Thursdays, when attendance dipped at the end of a long week, and now run on Mondays only. Attendance rose to 82%, and ten students did not miss a session.



IN CONVERSATION WITH ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION

Highlights from our interview with Robyn Mansfield, Judgemeadow Community College, October 2026.



Every student who takes up the tutoring is, as Ms Mansfield puts it, “not hitting their target grade in the subject”, and any rise from the mock counts. In 2026, 88% beat their Year 10 mock, up from 77% in the first year with Purple Ruler, and the other three held their grade, one of them a grade 9. The average hides bigger leaps: several students who scored a grade 2 in their mock left with a grade 5.


“Normally you see either one or two grade movement with considerable revision alongside that.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE



And once again, those who came to more than 80% of their sessions improved the most.


In their own words

One student who took part in the 2025-26 academic year, and has since left Judgemeadow, wrote about the tutoring for this story. What stood out for them was a private hour in which no question was too small to ask.


“Purple Ruler tuition helped me to achieve my desired grade, as it allowed me to ask questions I didn’t get the chance to ask my maths teachers, which was beneficial since it helps you to ask questions in a private conversation, so any ‘irrelevant’ questions could be asked, thus improving your understanding of the subject. The fact I achieved 2 grades higher than what I expected shows that it was one of the methods that catalysed that process. Overall, Purple tuition is great to improve your understanding of the subject, but it will not magically improve your grades; hard and efficient studying is needed.”

A FORMER STUDENT, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE


They were the maths student who came to every session in 2025-26 and went from a grade 4 to a grade 8. Their warning that tutoring “will not magically improve your grades” echoes Ms Mansfield’s own.


The outcomes that matter

Most of these students left Year 11 with a better grade than their mock predicted, in the subjects that decide what they study next, and those who came most often gained most. The combination of targeted tuition, classroom teaching and student commitment helped students achieve outcomes beyond those predicted by their mock examinations. On average they rose by 1.6 grades, nearly three times the half grade by which disadvantaged students fall behind nationally. Tutoring also does something the grades do not show. It “will build their confidence in the subject”, Ms Mansfield says.


“When you’ve got someone who’s committed to attend the tuition and use it effectively alongside their own hard work and commitment, it can really facilitate their learning and make a difference.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE


What scaling looks like

Judgemeadow has shared the method. Ms Mansfield set it out in Purple Ruler’s high-impact tutoring webinar in January 2026, the school joined Purple Ruler’s free summer maths programme, and a third cohort starts this year. For a trust, the design travels school by school, as the White Horse Federation found.


“Precision beats scale. Engagement drives outcomes. Tuition works best when it has a clear purpose and an end point.”

ROBYN MANSFIELD, PUPIL PREMIUM CHAMPION, JUDGEMEADOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE




Results figures come from Judgemeadow Community College's own impact reports on its 2024-25 and 2025-26 tutoring cohorts (December 2025 and August 2026), which compare each student's GCSE grade with their Year 10 mock grade. Both cohorts were taught by Purple Ruler. National figures come from the Department for Education's Key stage 4 performance releases: a Progress 8 score of -0.57 for disadvantaged students in 2023/24, the latest year it was calculated, and a 26.8 percentage point gap in grade 5 or above in English and maths in 2025/26. Lesson and tutor figures come from Purple Ruler's lesson register for the spring term 2026. Quotations from Robyn Mansfield come from her notes for Purple Ruler's January 2026 webinar and from an interview with Purple Ruler on 28 October 2026, to be confirmed by her at review. Student quotations come from paragraphs two former students wrote for this story in October 2026, shared by the school; one is used with a parent's consent. No student is named or identified, and Judgemeadow Community College and Lionheart Educational Trust approve the final copy before publication.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page